Stories
Amazon’s new Echo Studio adds a camera, and is pitched partly at low vision users
Amazon says the camera in its new screenless Echo Studio suits people with low vision, but Double Tap's Shaun Preece is not yet convinced it will work.
Listen to this article
Amazon has built a home camera into its new Echo Studio speaker, and at the launch the company made a point of saying who some of it is for: people who are blind or have low vision.
The event was held behind closed doors, so what is known comes from journalists who were there. Speaking on Double Tap, Steven Scott went through the shape of the speaker, the controls on it and what Amazon says the camera does.
“These ones apparently are better. Bearing in mind these Echo Studios are the cylindrical shape, they do have a slightly flat face with the buttons similar to the Echo Dot Max. You've got the volume up, the volume down, the mute button. But you don't have a screen on these, so these don't have screens, but this one does come with a camera, the home camera built in, and an optional stand which you can buy for more money. So here's what the… You can buy a stand for it, but you don't get the stand chucked in. They're going Apple on this, I tell you. So the camera handles live view, face recognition… and Alexa visual intelligence, and Amazon says it does not record. It also adds in this edition advanced room adaptation audio. And you can of course still buy the regular camera free Echo Studio, which stays on sale. It's the same device essentially, there's not a huge…”
Steven Scott
The case for the camera was made at the event by Amazon's Panos Panay. Steven explained what Panay said about blind and partially sighted customers, and what that would mean in practice for anyone wanting to know what they are holding.
“Well, I think it has to be Alexa Plus that does that. I mean, it's talking about visual intelligence, and again at the event Panos Panay stood up and said for a lot of people who are low vision or visually impaired… they don't want the screen, they don't need the screen, so having the camera means that you can use that show and tell feature. Now, they didn't refer to, I don't think, show and tell, but it would be essentially the ability to hold something up to the camera and say what is this, what am I holding, etc. So I'd be intrigued to try it. I don't know if I'm prepared to spend the money to figure out how much good this is. But so this one 249, so 250 dollars. Oh, by the way…”
Steven Scott
Shaun Preece was not persuaded. He said Amazon has already had cameras in its screen based Echo Show devices for years, and he has spent long enough in front of one to know how that goes.
“Again, much like the MacBook Pro touch, it needs that feature, it does need that killer feature to sell this, because we've had cameras in the Shows for a long time, and we've had, again back to our bubble, the show and tell feature, which sounded really good but in practice it wasn't great. The amount of times I stood in front of the Show with an unknown packet in front of me, and trying to get it in the frame and move closer and move further away, and it's a dog or something and it gets it completely wrong. So it's got to work. Now whether that's the Alexa Plus, the new AI, can maybe make this work as we want it to. This could be really good, but I'm not convinced yet.”
Shaun Preece
Steven said the camera free Echo Studio stays on sale at 219 dollars, which could suit anyone building a pair who does not want two cameras in the room. He also pointed out that these speakers can be connected to a Fire TV as surround sound, and that the built in camera could be used for video calls, although it was not made clear which service those calls would use.
For us, the idea is sound and the execution is everything. A speaker that reliably tells you what is in your hand would earn its place, but that depends entirely on the newer Alexa being better at it than the old show and tell feature was.
Hear the whole conversation in the full episode: Touchscreen MacBook Pro and Amazon's New Alexa+ Echo Lineup: Who Are They For?